A First Nation and chief in Manitoba’s Island Lake region say they won’t be able to properly govern if a court does not stop a group of people from defaming the current chief whom they attempted to oust following a financial update he gave.
Wasagamack Anisininew First Nation and Chief Jerry Knott are suing nine people for defamation, including former chief Walter Harper, according to a statement of claim filed at the Manitoba Court of King’s Bench on Nov. 9.
Also named as defendants are a former director of Wasagamack, a former capital projects officer, a former elder, a former vice chief and current councillor, a former tactical force officer, as well as three members of the First Nation.
The group planned to meet at Wasagamack’s community hall on Nov. 10 to plan Knott’s removal as chief, the lawsuit alleges.
Knott was elected chief of Wasagamack in May, replacing Walter Harper, the suit says. The election results were not appealed or overturned by anyone on the fly-in First Nation, located about 470 kilometres northeast of Winnipeg in the Island Lake region, the suit says.
Knott issued a letter to all community members on Oct. 15 regarding the First Nation’s financial status and its financial plans, and later issued supporting documents to all community and band members, according to the lawsuit.
After that update was given, Knott and the First Nation discovered “multiple and repeated attempts” by the defendants to interfere with, defame, and disparage the chief and the First Nation, the suit says.
None of the allegations have been proven in court.
Knott seeks injunctions that would prohibit, restrain and order the defendants from interfering with the administration, operations, and governance of the First Nation or Knott in his duties as chief, the suit says.
‘We don’t want another 30 years of dictatorship’: First Nation unites to oust ‘lifetime’ chief
He’s also asking the court for injunctions to prohibit, restrain and order the defendants not to make, publish or spread defamatory and/or disparaging statements and “injurious falsehoods” about the First Nation or himself.
He seeks another injunction that would prohibit, restrain and order the defendants — or anyone working with them or on their behalf — from holding public meetings with the purpose to interfere with, defame and disparage Wasagamack and himself, including the Nov. 10 meeting, the suit says.
On Oct. 13, the defendants issued a notice alerting the community to a public meeting that would be held to question Knott’s election, the suit says. They also demanded that all administrative offices be closed.
Three days after Knott’s financial update, the defendants issued a letter to the chief — it was later published in the community — alleging that Knott had “breached, broken, and contravened his oath of office,” and that he had “broken the privacy and confidentiality” of the Wasagamack’s financial status, according to the lawsuit.
Walter Harper, a former chief of Wasagamack First Nation, is seen in a 2023 file image. (Stephanie Cram/CBC)
On Oct. 22, the defendants issued a letter to a wide range of Wasagamack affiliates, programs, business clients and partners, saying it was “official notification” that Knott was “no longer the recognized chief” of Wasagamack after he “violated and breached his oath of office.”
The letter also directed all “future business dealings to acting chief Kelvin Harper until further notice,” according to the lawsuit. The group had previous knowledge of the First Nation’s “economic and contractual relations” with the people they contacted, the suit says.
The defendants’ letters about Knott “sparked outrage and disparaging comments” against him and the First Nation, damaging their reputations and constituting defamation, the lawsuit alleges.
“Instead of appealing the election, the defendants appear to have fostered and encouraged outrage and disparaging comments” about Knott and Wasagamack through their letters, the suit alleges.
Knott and Wasagamack have repeatedly demanded that the defendants stop the conduct detailed in the lawsuit, but the group has “failed, refused or neglected” to do so, the statement of claim alleges.
Knott and the First Nation say they’ve “suffered, are suffering, and will continue to suffer serious and irreparable harm” unless the court intervenes.
“On the foregoing facts, without intervention, Chief Knott and Wasagamack will not be able to administer, operate and govern the First Nation,” the suit says.
Ousted Caldwell First Nation chief seeks reinstatement and legal fees, she says after hearing
The lawsuit also accuses the nine defendants of conspiring and instructing others to “actively and intentionally mislead, and confuse, to continue to injure, and harm” Knott and Wasagamack.
The group damaged Knott’s and the First Nation’s reputations and they knew, or should have known, that the statements they were circulating about Knott were false, the lawsuit argues
Knott and Wasagamack also allege the nine defendants unlawfully interfered with their economic and contractual relations, resulting in damages, loss, costs and expenses.
The chief and First Nation say they’ve suffered the loss of their ability to properly run and govern the community. Knott and Wasagamack provide “valuable and significant services which stand in jeopardy on account of the egregious and shameful conduct” of the nine defendants.
Knott and Wasagamack are seeking a range of damages, including aggravated and punitive damages, with specific amounts to be determined at a trial.
CBC News has reached out to Knott and Harper for comment but did not hear back prior to publication.










